Monday, November 16, 2026Latest
Opinion

Medicaid Work Rules Got Six More Months. Use Them to Prove the Government Can Do Its Own Job

The federal government just gave states six more months to enforce Medicaid work requirements. I think that's the most honest thing anyone in this fight has done lately. A deadline extension is an admission that the machinery isn't ready. The real question is what gets built in those six months, and who answers for it if it isn't built.

Here's where I stand, so nobody has to guess. I have no problem asking able-bodied adults to work, train, or volunteer in exchange for taxpayer-funded coverage. Public trust in assistance is fragile, and pretending fraud and dependency never happen is the fastest way to lose it. I run a food pantry. I want the programs that exist for genuine need to survive, and that means they have to be defensible to the people paying for them.

But a requirement isn't a policy. It's a promise that somebody will check. Checking means verifying hours, collecting documents, processing them, sending notices, and fixing mistakes. That's paperwork, run by agencies, and the test of any work requirement is whether the system enforcing it can tell a person who isn't working from a person whose form got lost.

Stack of forms and a magnifying glass symbolizing verification.
Stack of forms and a magnifying glass symbolizing verification.

Ask the questions I always ask. Who has the authority to make sure the wrong person doesn't lose coverage? Who owns the next step when the system gets it wrong? When will it be fixed? If nobody can answer those three questions before the enforcement date, the policy isn't ready, no matter how good it sounds at a podium.

Now look at the double standard. Ordinary people will be expected to prove themselves by a deadline, with documents, on the government's schedule. The agencies in charge just got a six-month grace period because they weren't ready. Nobody is going to give a working family six more months to dig up a pay stub. I'm not saying the delay is wrong. Launching a mess is worse than launching late. I'm saying the standard only ever runs in one direction.

So here's what I'd demand during that time, and none of it is complicated. First, publish the plan: who verifies, how, using what data, and who is accountable. Second, use what the state already knows before asking people to prove it. Making a citizen hand over information the government already holds is lazy administration, not accountability. Third, put a human being on the other end, with a phone number answered by someone who has the authority to fix a problem and not just log it. Fourth, put the burden of error on the agency. If the state's mistake drops somebody, coverage continues until the state corrects it.

Automated food locker unit representing efficient public service.
Automated food locker unit representing efficient public service.

That last one matters because a person who loses coverage over a clerical error doesn't stop being sick. The cost doesn't disappear. It lands in an emergency room, in a household budget, in a pantry line. Anyone who says a few wrongful terminations are an acceptable price hasn't thought about where the bill goes. Cutting someone off by accident saves nothing. It just moves the cost somewhere less visible.

Look at what's happening elsewhere in the news. U-M Sparrow Eaton has put in smart food lockers so people can get nutritious food around the clock. Lansing is working out a warming center while the city debates a moratorium on homeless sweeps. Those are the efforts that actually move things, because someone looked at a problem and built a system with a name on it. Nobody had to mandate it. Somebody owned it.

I also want this policy measured honestly. If the point is to move people into work, then the test is whether people end up working. If all it does is shrink the rolls through paperwork attrition, it isn't a work requirement. It's a budget cut dressed up as a character lesson, and the public deserves to be told which one they bought. Publish the results and let people judge.

Balance scale weighing documents against a person icon.
Balance scale weighing documents against a person icon.

Both camps are letting the agencies off the hook. One side says any requirement is cruelty, which ignores the legitimate case for accountability in public programs. The other side says the occasional wrongful loss of coverage is the cost of doing business, which ignores that the people paying that cost are the ones with the least ability to fight back. Neither position demands that the government do its own job well.

Six months is enough time to build something competent if someone is willing to own it. I'd rather see this done right and a little slow than fast and broken. I'll be watching to see whether the state uses this time to build a system that treats people like citizens, or just a bigger pile of forms. I'd love to be wrong about the second one.

Leave a Reply