Monday, November 16, 2026Latest
National

Law professors challenge new York Times claim that Second Amendment test rests on misquote

Law professors are disputing a recent New York Times article that claimed the Supreme Court's pivotal second amendment legal test is based on a misquote of Sir William Blackstone. The NYT reported that Justice Antonin Scalia incorrectly cited Blackstone's 1769 treatise as using the phrase "dangerous and unusual" when the original text actually read "dangerous or unusual." This distinction matters because the conjunctive phrasing suggests a narrower category of weapons subject to restriction than the disjunctive original.

However, the professors argue the Times reporters overlooked standard legal citation practices. They note that the Supreme Court's style guide uses the "See" signal to indicate that cited authorities support a proposition without necessarily stating it verbatim. Furthermore, the string of citations following Scalia's opinion includes multiple sources that do use "and," suggesting the historical tradition supports the court's interpretation regardless of Blackstone's specific wording.

The dispute deepened after one of the Times authors contacted John Bash, who clerked for Justice Scalia during the Heller case. Bash explained that the chronological ordering of citations and the mixed nature of historical sources meant there was no actual error in the landmark ruling. Despite receiving this explanation before publication, the Times article asserted the misquote without qualification, prompting the current pushback from legal scholars.

Read the full story at reason.com.

Leave a Reply