Clarence Thomas warns First Amendment protections May erode under heavy regulation
Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas issued a warning about First Amendment protections on Monday after the court declined to hear Khatibi v. Yip, a challenge to a California requirement governing continuing medical education courses. Thomas, joined by Samuel Alito, dissented from the refusal, arguing that a federal appeals court fundamentally misunderstood when speech should be treated as the government's own rather than constitutionally protected private expression.
The decision left the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals' judgment in place without deciding the case on the merits, meaning California's requirement for instructors to address implicit bias survives this particular challenge. Thomas argued that the lower court's application of the Shurtleff v. Boston framework threatens to create a broader principle where extensive government regulation effectively converts private expression into government speech.
Caleb Trotter, an attorney with the Pacific Legal Foundation, stated that continuing medical education instructors now have less First Amendment protection than government employees or public school teachers when speaking in their official duties. While the Supreme Court did not establish a new nationwide rule, Thomas suggested the court should reconsider the Shurtleff test to prevent lower courts from concluding that heavy regulation turns private speech into government orthodoxy.
Read the full story at Newsweek.
